2024-09-29 23:39 UTC
Replies (1)
-
@abucci@buc.ci 2024-09-30 00:56
@anschmidtlebuhn@scholar.social @adityakhanna@mathstodon.xyz @timnitGebru@dair-community.social For the sake of anyone interested let me spell it out. Yes, it's correct that the Minsky quote in the OP did not mention IQ. I added that myself. I'm not sure if Minsky ever talked about IQ, but that's not what I was suggesting or talking about. If I'd been more careful I'd have clarified that Minsky's work suggests his view of intelligence meshed well with the notion that you can somehow measure it in a way analogous to how you measure physical quantities, and that this in turn is a view eugenicists hold dear. The Minsky quote was from SciAm or Life I think, a popular science thing. His work, if you followed it at all, was very much about constructing disembodied intelligence, or what he thought of as intelligence anyway. This is very much in the spirit of how IQ and similar metrics conceive of intelligence. Rather than a phenomenon woven through the whole person and their history, intelligence is viewed as something that can be abstracted and defined, fractioned away not just from the person but from any person, put into a machine, and measured like you'd measure mass. Society of Mind really lays out the bit about abstracting intelligence away from a person and their history. And that notion, that intelligence can be fractioned off and measured, that was and is a darling of eugenicists. No, I'm not saying Minsky was a eugenicist, just that this way of looking at intelligence is alarmingly close to what eugenicists think and how they think. Plus, "be at genius level" is just a cringe thing to say. How weird. Once again I don't know if Minsky meant it this way, but it's common to equate "genius" with IQ score. Dictionary definitions do this for instance. Lewis Terman, an outspoken eugenicist, started the Genetic Studies of Genius at Stanford, an institution founded by a eugenicist, that grounded "genius" in IQ score. I find it difficult to believe Minsky was unaware of these associations but who knows.